Chelsea Player Ratings vs Sunderland: Levi Colwill’s Penalty Costs as Blues Stumble at Stadium of Light
Chelsea dominated possession with 69%, but failed to turn control into goals, losing 1-0 at Sunderland’s Stadium of Light. A penalty by Enzo Le Fee in the 36th minute decided the game, exposing Chelsea’s struggles breaking down Sunderland’s deep defensive block.
Match Overview
Xabi Alonso’s team held the ball well, registering 10 shots and more corners than Sunderland, yet lacked penetration. The absence of Emiliano Martinez and Reece James was felt, especially as Chelsea couldn’t find verticality in attack. Sunderland’s compact defense forced Chelsea to rely on substitutions like Estevao and Danny Welbeck, but chances remained limited. Chelsea’s Expected Goals (xG) was just 1.158 compared to Sunderland’s 2.44, highlighting inefficiency and tactical challenges in this match.
Goalkeeper & Defence
- Mike Penders - 6/10: Stepped in for the injured Martinez. Could do nothing about the penalty, made only one save, and maintained safe distribution contributing to Chelsea’s high possession.
- Marco Palestra - 5/10: Lacked the attacking width needed to stretch Sunderland. Reliable in possession but replaced in the 62nd minute for Malo Gusto to add offensive threat.
- Pep Chavarria - 5/10: Had a tough day dealing with Sunderland’s quick transitions and was taken off late as Chelsea pushed for an equalizer.
- Levi Colwill - 4/10: A costly error from Colwill led to the decisive penalty. He also received a yellow card before being substituted at halftime.
- Wesley Fofana - 6/10: More composed among defenders, recorded many clearances but was booked in stoppage time.
Midfield
- Romeo Lavia - 6/10: Controlled the midfield base and recycled possession effectively but struggled to break through Sunderland’s disciplined midfield.
- Cole Palmer - 6/10: Quiet creatively, often crowded out by defenders and unable to deliver key passes.
- Moises Caicedo - 7/10: Captain showed consistent energy disrupting Sunderland’s counter-attacks and regaining possession before being subbed in the 76th minute.
- Jordan Henderson - 5/10: Played further forward but failed to make a significant impact or test Sunderland’s keeper, replaced late in the game.
Attack
- Morgan Rogers - 6/10: Displayed strength and drive but lacked finishing quality, part of four shots on target that couldn’t trouble Sunderland’s goalkeeper.
- Pedro Neto - 5/10: Booked early and struggled to take on defenders, contributing little to Chelsea’s attack.
Substitutes & Manager
- Estevao - 6/10: Introduced at halftime for Colwill, brought some attacking spark but couldn’t break down Sunderland’s defense.
- Danny Welbeck - 5/10: Came on to lead the attack but was starved of quality crosses, which were inaccurate throughout the match.
- Malo Gusto - 6/10: Added more threat going forward after replacing Palestra, though delivery was inconsistent.
- Geovany Quenda - N/A: Late substitute with little time to influence the game.
- Emmanuel Emegha - N/A: Entered near the end as a final effort.
- Xabi Alonso - 5/10: Despite dominating possession, his side could not score. Starting Colwill backfired, and substitutions did not break Sunderland’s resilience.




