nigeriasport.ng

Residents Battle Bright Lights from Junction Oval in Albert Park

At 10pm in Albert Park, the scoreboard is blank, the stands are quiet – and the real contest is playing out in the apartments across Queens Rd.

John should be in bed. Instead, he’s pacing the streets, pushed out of his own home by the glare from Cricket Victoria’s new light towers at Junction Oval. The LEDs, he says, are “bright as hell”. His sanctuary no longer feels like one.

Seventeen floors up, Andrew reaches for something you’d expect on a blazing summer afternoon, not a school-night evening: sunglasses. His apartment “lights up like a Christmas tree” when the Junction Oval beams hit the glass. Photos taken from his place look like dawn is breaking. The reality is far more artificial.

Blockout blinds don’t stand a chance. Light slices through gaps, bounces off splashbacks, ricochets off internal glass walls. Three floors below, James doesn’t need a radio or a live score app to know when there’s a wicket or a boundary. The strobing celebrations seep through the edges of his blinds, turning his room into a disco before the full glare returns.

This is life now for residents around Junction Oval – at least two nights a week, sometimes up to four – since Cricket Victoria switched on four 50-metre light towers in August, built to help broadcast women’s cricket.

On paper, there are safeguards. The rules say the towers can’t be used after 11pm for broadcast or streamed events, or after 10pm for other fixtures. Another 30 minutes is allowed for patrons and staff to leave, with lighting capped at 10 lux in that window. The lights can only be used on 45 days each calendar year.

Residents say the reality is very different.

They claim the towers have already chewed through almost half that 45-day quota in just a few months, with nights spent on testing, matches and training. They talk about lights blazing when no one appears to be on the field at all, and training sessions lit up despite other “less invasive lights” being available.

Locals saw this coming. When the project was first floated, nearby residents launched a change.org petition, warning that four towering LED structures would fundamentally alter life in the area. More than 500 people signed. The petition lost. The multimillion-dollar project went ahead.

‘Living in a box’

James bought his apartment 12 years ago for one reason: the view over Albert Park. Open sky. Green space. Room to breathe.

Now, the moment the lights flick on, that view is gone.

“As soon as the lights switch on,” he said, his home becomes “a box”.

“They turn the lights on even though it’s daylight savings. They turn them on about 6pm and the amount of light that comes through the apartment, even with the blinds drawn. We’re effectively living in a box.

“Then there’s the strobing lights when they catch a ball or something … we’ve got glass inside our apartment as well so it reflects off the splashback, the internal glass walls, it’s terrible.”

Dinner, once a simple family ritual, has turned tactical. They now sit at different ends of the table to dodge the glare.

For John, the impact is not just irritating. It’s physical. He has a degenerative cornea and hyperthyroidism, both of which heighten his sensitivity to light.

“I end up getting really bad migraines and headaches,” he said. “So if I’m in my apartment which is your home, your safe place where you feel secure, it just feels very violating having these lights on.

“I leave the house. I literally do not want to be at home when the lights are on and I’ll get home at 11pm purely because the lights reflect off my TV into my bedroom … and I have zero interest in being at home when the lights are on.

“Even driving home along Queens Rd, as I’m pulling into the building, I need to have sun visors down in the car because (the lights) are blinding.”

He worries about people with photosensitive epilepsy caught unaware when pyrotechnics and strobing effects kick in.

“Anyone with photosensitive epilepsy could have an episode so that is also a risk if let’s say someone in the neighbouring building or even in our building has photo sensitive epilepsy and an attack is triggered by the lights,” he said. “Who’s actually evaluated that risk? Or who’s taking that into consideration?”

Andrew and his partner decided not to wait for an answer. They moved out.

“Other people don’t have that opportunity,” he said.

He still owns the apartment and rents it out. When he recently returned to clean up after a tenant moved out, the emotional hit was immediate.

“I think it’s ruined the beauty of the area, even when I go back there now I just look at it and I’m taken away from the view and beauty of it all,” he said.

“But the lights, oh my god, it’s like living next to the MCG. I remember them going in and feeling so violated that we had no control over the four 50-metre-high lights being built right in front of our home.”

Residents say the impact stretches beyond high-rise owners and renters. They’re also worried about “vulnerable” people sleeping rough in a nearby homeless encampment, forced to endure the same relentless glare without the luxury of blinds or double glazing.

‘A bit of a farce’

For all the sleepless nights and drawn blinds, the official record tells a different story.

An independent engineering audit, quietly submitted to the state government, declared the 50-metre towers “generally compliant” with Australian standards and in need of “no remedial measures”.

“No material exceedances attributable to the Junction Oval lighting installation were identified, and no remedial measures are considered necessary based on the assessment undertaken,” the Lucid Consulting report stated.

The audit did find two spots on Lakeside Drive where light levels exceeded the 25 lux limit. The report attributed that to pre-existing streetlights and “mild humidity” scattering light in the night air, and dismissed it as a concern.

Residents weren’t convinced. They pointed out the report “made no mention of Queens Rd”, where most of the high-rise apartments stare directly at the oval, and that measurements were taken at ground level – not at the height where people actually live.

“The report makes no mention of Queens Rd, no mention of the apartment buildings within 50 to 200 metres of the towers and no mention of any measurement of line-of-sight intrusion into surrounding apartments,” James said.

At least eight formal complaints have gone in to various authorities – Cricket Victoria, Port Phillip Council, Parks Victoria – but residents say the response has been silence or handballing.

They also argue that community consultation before the lights went in was rushed and superficial, with little of their feedback reflected in the final plan.

“There was no concern of what the broader community wanted,” John said.

He recalls a single session with Cricket Victoria, with notices dropped into letterboxes on the very day of the meeting.

“They were all hand delivered or put in our letter boxes on the day of the meeting so there were some very shady mannerisms.”

The meeting itself, he said, felt like “a bit of a farce”.

“The question I asked at the meeting was how comfortable would you feel having a street light flash into your bedroom window,” John said.

“And they kept beating around the bush not giving a straight answer and I literally told them it’s a yes or no answer … we never got anywhere.

“We had that one consultation session where we said the lights need to be reduced in height and there was no sort of consultation that happened after it. It was sort of like, ‘this is what we’re doing. Either accept it or there’s nothing you can do about it’.”

Cricket Victoria tells a different story. A spokeswoman said community consultation began in March and April 2025, including direct mail notifications to neighbouring residents and an open forum at Junction Oval.

“Community members were also invited to sign up to a mailing list – Friends of Junction Oval – to receive relevant project updates,” she said.

Who’s in charge?

Legally, Cricket Victoria stands on firm ground. The towers were approved under a special ministerial planning amendment that bypassed local council, locking in the 45-day cap and curfews.

Ask who is actually responsible for enforcing those conditions, though, and the answers get murky.

Port Phillip Council was first to step away. City of Port Phillip chief Chris Carroll said the light towers were approved by the Victorian Government, the site sits on Crown land, and Parks Victoria manages Albert Park Reserve.

“While Council has no regulatory role, we have engaged in discussions with Cricket Victoria to advocate on behalf of our community and seek practical solutions to address concerns raised,” he said.

Local MP for Albert Park, Nina Taylor, said her office had passed on objections to the light installation back in early 2025.

“My office received a number of objections to the proposed Junction Oval Light Tower Installation in early 2025,” she said.

“In every case, I forwarded the objection to Cricket Victoria and asked that their submission be registered as part of their community consultation process.”

She did not address residents’ current complaints.

Parks Victoria, the appointed land manager for Albert Park Reserve, did not officially comment. It is understood to hold regular meetings with Cricket Victoria, where issues raised by residents can be discussed. When pressed, Parks Victoria pointed to the Department of Transport and Planning.

A department spokesman said it had worked with Cricket Victoria and Port Phillip City Council “to support improved sporting infrastructure at Junction Oval”.

“Cricket Victoria has submitted an independent assessment of the lighting system, which we’re now reviewing,” he said.

Cricket Victoria, for its part, has stressed the upside. A spokeswoman said the organisation is working with local businesses on Fitzroy Street so they can benefit from “economic opportunities from increased attendances”.

“Cricket Victoria remains committed to engaging constructively with our local community,” she said.

“The lights have been used for training on a small number of evenings which fall within the approved maximum of 45 nights of use per year.

“It is important for our male and female cricketers to be able to train under evening conditions like our competitors across the country.”

Cricket Victoria did not answer questions about how it is directly managing complaints from residents at 83 Queens Rd.

For now, the towers stand, the fixtures roll on, and the residents keep counting the nights and the lux levels. Their next move? Exploring what legal or regulatory levers might still exist to dim the lights to something approaching a tolerable glow.

In Albert Park, the fight isn’t over the result on the scoreboard. It’s over who gets to control the night.